Evansville's Finest

Every sip
designed
to delight

Handcrafted beverages and artisan desserts, made with intention and served with warmth — because your daily ritual deserves to be extraordinary.

Explore Our Menu (812) 625-1087

Artisan coffee being poured in an elegant cup at Milk & Sugar Scoop Shoppe

10933

IN-66, Evansville

Curated Selection

Our Menu

From single-origin espressos to handcrafted desserts, every item on our menu is a commitment to quality and taste.

Coffee & Beverages

Crafted with precision

Espresso

Rich, bold, perfectly extracted

Cappuccino

Velvety steamed milk, double shot

Latte

Silky microfoam, your choice of syrup

Cold Brew

20-hour steep, smooth finish

Matcha Latte

Ceremonial grade, oat or dairy

Artisan Hot Chocolate

Belgian chocolate, whipped cream

Desserts & Treats

Baked with passion daily

Cheesecake

New York style, seasonal toppings

Chocolate Lava Cake

Molten center, vanilla gelato

Croissants

Butter, chocolate, or almond

Tiramisu

Classic Italian, mascarpone cream

Ice Cream Scoops

House-made, rotating flavors

Seasonal Specials

Ask your barista for today's creation

Oat, almond, and soy milk available · Gluten-free options · Vegan desserts upon request

Elegant café interior with warm lighting at Milk & Sugar Scoop Shoppe

Barista pouring latte art at Milk & Sugar Scoop Shoppe

Artisan dessert display case at Milk & Sugar Scoop Shoppe

Freshly roasted coffee beans at Milk & Sugar Scoop Shoppe

Our Story

A place where
every detail
matters

Milk & Sugar Scoop Shoppe was born from a simple belief: that the ordinary moments of your day — your morning coffee, your afternoon pause, your weekend treat — deserve to be exceptional.

Located on IN-66 in Evansville, we've created a space where craft coffee meets genuine hospitality. Our beans are carefully sourced, our desserts are made fresh daily, and our team treats every guest like a valued friend.

Whether you're grabbing a quick espresso on your way to work or settling in for a leisurely afternoon with a slice of cheesecake, we want this to be the highlight of your day.

100%

Arabica Beans

Daily

Fresh Baked

∞

Warmth Served

Gallery